Its original naming hides the fact that it's related to datalog
polonius, and bound to be deleted in the near future.
It also conflicts with the expected name for the actual NLL location
map, and prefixing it with its use will make the differentiation
possible.
`best_blame_constraint`: Blame better constraints when the region graph has cycles from invariance or `'static`
This fixes#132749 by changing which constraint is blamed for region errors in several cases. `best_blame_constraint` had a heuristic that tried to pinpoint the constraint causing an error by filtering out any constraints where the outliving region is unified with the ultimate target region being outlived. However, it used the SCCs of the region graph to do this, which is unreliable; in particular, if the target region is `'static`, or if there are cycles from the presence of invariant types, it was skipping over the constraints it should be blaming. As is the case in that issue, this could lead to confusing diagnostics. The simplest fix seems to work decently, judging by test stderr: this makes `best_blame_constraint` no longer filter constraints by their outliving region's SCC.
There are admittedly some quirks in the test output. In many cases, subdiagnostics that depend on the particular constraint being blamed have either started or stopped being emitted. After starting at this for quite a while, I think anything too fickle about whether it outputs based on the particular constraint being blamed should instead be looking at the constraint path as a whole, similar to what's done for [the placeholder-from-predicate note](https://github.com/rust-lang/rust/compare/master...dianne:rust:better-blame-constraints-for-static#diff-3c0de6462469af483c9ecdf2c4b00cb26192218ef2d5c62a0fde75107a74caaeR506).
Very many tests involving invariant types gained a note pointing out the types' invariance, but in a few cases it was lost. A particularly illustrative example is [tests/ui/lifetimes/copy_modulo_regions.stderr](https://github.com/rust-lang/rust/compare/master...dianne:rust:better-blame-constraints-for-static?expand=1#diff-96e1f8b29789b3c4ce2f77a5e0fba248829b97ef9d1ce39e7d2b4aa57b2cf4f0); I'd argue the new constraint is a better one to blame, but it lacks the variance diagnostic information that's elsewhere in the constraint path. If desired, I can try making that note check the whole path rather than just the blamed constraint.
The subdiagnostic [`BorrowExplanation::add_object_lifetime_default_note`](https://doc.rust-lang.org/nightly/nightly-rustc/rustc_borrowck/diagnostics/explain_borrow/enum.BorrowExplanation.html#method.add_object_lifetime_default_note) depends on a `Cast` being blamed, so [a special case](364ca7f99c) was necessary to keep it from disappearing from tests specifically testing for it. However, see the FIXME comment in that commit; I think the special case should be removed once that subdiagnostic works properly, but it's nontrivial enough to warrant a separate PR. Incidentally, this removes the note from a test where it was being added erroneously: in [tests/ui/borrowck/two-phase-surprise-no-conflict.stderr](https://github.com/rust-lang/rust/compare/master...dianne:rust:better-blame-constraints-for-static?expand=1#diff-8cf085af8203677de6575a45458c9e6b03412a927df879412adec7e4f7ff5e14), the object lifetime is explicitly provided and it's not `'static`.
Begin to implement type system layer of unsafe binders
Mostly TODOs, but there's a lot of match arms that are basically just noops so I wanted to split these out before I put up the MIR lowering/projection part of this logic.
r? oli-obk
Tracking:
- https://github.com/rust-lang/rust/issues/130516
Foundations of location-sensitive polonius
I'd like to land the prototype I'm describing in the [polonius project goal](https://github.com/rust-lang/rust-project-goals/issues/118). It still is incomplete and naive and terrible but it's working "well enough" to consider landing.
I'd also like to make review easier by not opening a huge PR, but have a couple small-ish ones (the +/- line change summary of this PR looks big, but >80% is moving datalog to a single place).
This PR starts laying the foundation for that work:
- it refactors and collects 99% of the old datalog fact gen, which was spread around everywhere, into a single dedicated module. It's still present at 3 small places (one of which we should revert anyways) that are kinda deep within localized components and are not as easily extractable into the rest of fact gen, so it's fine for now.
- starts introducing the localized constraints, the building blocks of the naive way of implementing the location-sensitive analysis in-tree, which is roughly sketched out in https://smallcultfollowing.com/babysteps/blog/2023/09/22/polonius-part-1/ and https://smallcultfollowing.com/babysteps/blog/2023/09/29/polonius-part-2/ but with a different vibe than per-point environments described in these posts, just `r1@p: r2@q` constraints.
- sets up the skeleton of generating these localized constraints: converting NLL typeck constraints, and creating liveness constraints
- introduces the polonius dual to NLL MIR to help development and debugging. It doesn't do much currently but is a way to see these localized constraints: it's an NLL MIR dump + a dumb listing of the constraints, that can be dumped with `-Zdump-mir=polonius -Zpolonius=next`. Its current state is not intended to be a long-term thing, just for testing purposes -- I will replace its contents in the future with a different approach (an HTML+js file where we can more easily explore/filter/trace these constraints and loan reachability, have mermaid graphs of the usual graphviz dumps, etc).
I've started documenting the approach in this PR, I'll add more in the future. It's quite simple, and should be very clear when more constraints are introduced anyways.
r? `@matthewjasper`
Best reviewed per commit so that the datalog move is less bothersome to read, but if you'd prefer we separate that into a different PR, I can do that (and michael has offered to review these more mechanical changes if it'd help).
The words "before" and "after" have an obvious temporal meaning, e.g.
`seek_before_primary_effect`,
`visit_statement_{before,after}_primary_effect`. But "before" is also
used to name the effect that occurs before the primary effect of a
statement/terminator; this is `Effect::Before`. This leads to the
confusing possibility of talking about things happening "before/after
the before event".
This commit removes this awkward overloading of "before" by renaming
`Effect::Before` as `Effect::Early`. It also renames some of the
`Analysis` and `ResultsVisitor` methods to be more consistent.
Here are the before and after names:
- `Effect::{Before,Primary}` -> `Effect::{Early,Primary}`
- `apply_before_statement_effect` -> `apply_early_statement_effect`
- `apply_statement_effect` -> `apply_primary_statement_effect`
- `visit_statement_before_primary_effect` -> `visit_after_early_statement_effect`
- `visit_statement_after_primary_effect` -> `visit_after_primary_statement_effect`
(And s/statement/terminator/ for all the terminator events.)
They are only present because it's currently defined in terms of the
domains of `Borrows` and `MaybeUninitializedPlaces` and
`EverInitializedPlaces` via associated types. This commit introduces
typedefs for those domains, avoiding the lifetimes.
It's a performance win because `MixedBitSet` is faster and uses less
memory than `ChunkedBitSet`.
Also reflow some overlong comment lines in
`lint_tail_expr_drop_order.rs`.
take 2
open up coroutines
tweak the wordings
the lint works up until 2021
We were missing one case, for ADTs, which was
causing `Result` to yield incorrect results.
only include field spans with significant types
deduplicate and eliminate field spans
switch to emit spans to impl Drops
Co-authored-by: Niko Matsakis <nikomat@amazon.com>
collect drops instead of taking liveness diff
apply some suggestions and add explantory notes
small fix on the cache
let the query recurse through coroutine
new suggestion format with extracted variable name
fine-tune the drop span and messages
bugfix on runtime borrows
tweak message wording
filter out ecosystem types earlier
apply suggestions
clippy
check lint level at session level
further restrict applicability of the lint
translate bid into nop for stable mir
detect cycle in type structure
Now that `Results` is the only impl of `ResultsVisitable`, the trait can
be removed. This simplifies things by removining unnecessary layers of
indirection and abstraction.
- `ResultsVisitor` is simpler.
- Its type parameter changes from `R` (an analysis result) to the
simpler `A` (an analysis).
- It no longer needs the `Domain` associated type, because it can use
`A::Domain`.
- Occurrences of `R` become `Results<'tcx, A>`, because there is now
only one kind of analysis results.
- `save_as_intervals` also changes type parameter from `R` to `A`.
- The `results.reconstruct_*` method calls are replaced with
`results.analysis.apply_*` method calls, which are equivalent.
- `Direction::visit_results_in_block` is simpler, with a single generic
param (`A`) instead of two (`D` and `R`/`F`, with a bound connecting
them). Likewise for `visit_results`.
- The `ResultsVisitor` impls for `MirBorrowCtxt` and
`StorageConflictVisitor` are now specific about the type of the
analysis results they work with. They both used to have a type param
`R` but they weren't genuinely generic. In both cases there was only a
single results type that made sense to instantiate them with.
The results of most analyses end up in a `Results<'tcx, A>`, where `A`
is the analysis. It's then possible to traverse the results via a
`ResultsVisitor`, which relies on the `ResultsVisitable` trait. (That
trait ends up using the same `apply_*` methods that were used when
computing the analysis, albeit indirectly.)
This pattern of "compute analysis results, then visit them" is common.
But there is one exception. For borrow checking we compute three
separate analyses (`Borrows`, `MaybeUninitializedPlaces`, and
`EverInitializedPlaces`), combine them into a single `BorrowckResults`,
and then do a single visit of that `BorrowckResults` with
`MirBorrowckResults`. `BorrowckResults` is just different enough from
`Results` that it requires the existence of `ResultsVisitable`, which
abstracts over the traversal differences between `Results` and
`BorrowckResults`.
This commit changes things by introducing `Borrowck` and bundling the
three borrowck analysis results into a standard `Results<Borrowck>`
instead of the exceptional `BorrowckResults`. Once that's done, the
results can be visited like any other analysis results.
`BorrowckResults` is removed, as is `impl ResultsVisitable for
BorrowckResults`. (It's instructive to see how similar the added `impl
Analysis for Borrowck` is to the removed `impl ResultsVisitable for
BorrowckResults`. They're both doing exactly the same things.)
Overall this increases the number of lines of code and might not seem
like a win. But it enables the removal of `ResultsVisitable` in the next
commit, which results in many simplifications.
- Store a mut ref to a `BorrowckDiags` in `MirBorrowckCtxt` instead of
owning it, to save having to pass ownership in and out of
`promoted_mbcx`.
- Use `buffer_error` in a couple of suitable places.
This is a standard pattern:
```
MyAnalysis.into_engine(tcx, body).iterate_to_fixpoint()
```
`into_engine` and `iterate_to_fixpoint` are always called in pairs, but
sometimes with a builder-style `pass_name` call between them. But a
builder-style interface is overkill here. This has been bugging me a for
a while.
This commit:
- Merges `Engine::new` and `Engine::iterate_to_fixpoint`. This removes
the need for `Engine` to have fields, leaving it as a trivial type
that the next commit will remove.
- Renames `Analysis::into_engine` as `Analysis::iterate_to_fixpoint`,
gives it an extra argument for the optional pass name, and makes it
call `Engine::iterate_to_fixpoint` instead of `Engine::new`.
This turns the pattern from above into this:
```
MyAnalysis.iterate_to_fixpoint(tcx, body, None)
```
which is shorter at every call site, and there's less plumbing required
to support it.
- fix for divergence
- fix error message
- fix another cranelift test
- fix some cranelift things
- don't set the NORETURN option for naked asm
- fix use of naked_asm! in doc comment
- fix use of naked_asm! in run-make test
- use `span_bug` in unreachable branch
The `regioncx` and `borrow_set` fields can be references instead of
`Rc`. They use the existing `'a` lifetime. This avoids some heap
allocations and is a bit simpler.
